• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Best Bets
  • Upcoming Shows
  • All Reviews
  • Bay Area Theatres
  • About Eddie
  • Contact
Theatre Eddys

Theatre Eddys

San Francisco Bay Area Theater Reviews

The Comedy of Errors

April 24, 2025 by Eddie Reynolds Leave a Comment

The Comedy of Errors

William Shakespeare, with Modern Verse Translation by Christina Anderson

American Conservatory Theater, A Touring Production by the Acting Company

Jeffrey Rashad & James RIcardo Milord

What a difference a week can make!  A week ago, New York’s touring Acting Company opened at American Conservatory Theatre a must-see, poetic play of powerful prose about a turbulent, turning point period in American history (August Wilson’s Two Trains Running, part of his ten-play cycle about the Black, 20th century experience).  Now, the same renowned company opens in their two-production repertory a wild and wacky The Comedy of Errors — one so full of silliness and slapstick that the iambic pentameter words of William Shakespeare take a back seat and are at times completely lost in the jiving and the street-style translation by Christina Anderson as directed by Devin Brain.  The contrast is impressive as this collection of talented actors switches gears big time, but their second offering does not altogether measure up to the first as this staged comedy on steroids at times just tries too hard to get one more laugh.

Set again in the same 1960’s-style diner as Two Trains (Tanya Orellana, scenic designer), the evening opens with a raspy-voiced, near-deranged Aegean (Diana Coates) telling a harrowing tale to four, wide-eyed “lads” kneeling in front of him — two pairs of grown men with each pair dressed in identical clothes.  Aegean recounts a ship-wreck where he and his wife are each separated at sea with one twin son and with one twin servant of that son. Aegean and his paired half finally land in Syracuse, and the other threesome, reportedly in Ephesus.  The tale is lit by Jared Gooding as if we were watching a movie screen while Lindsay Jones’s sound design is one filled with mighty claps of thunder, a ship’s breaking into pieces, and music from a 1930’s adventure movie.

After the stage clears during a black-out, a twosome crawls out from behind the diner’s jukebox, as the snazzy-dressed Antipholus of Syracuse (Jame Ricardo Milord) and his loyal servant and sidekick Dromio (Chuckie Benson) arrive in the arch enemy territory of Ephesus looking for their long-lost, twin counterparts.  (We are to believe, of course, that Ephesus is in the form of a Hill District diner in Pittsburg.)  

James Ricardo Milord & Deanna Supplee

As the the Syracuse duo roams (inside the diner) the same streets as do their duplicates — Antipholus and Dromio of Ephesus (Jeffrey Rashad and J’Laney Allen, respectively) — mix-ups and misidentifications by the dozens ensue.  A wife (Adriana, Deanna Supplee) ends up in bed with the wrong husband.  A sister-in-law (Diana Coates again) falls heads over heels in love with whom she knows she shouldn’t.  A courtesan (Diana Coats, now decked in red fur) tempts one twin to bed and demands, with threat of a scandal, a promised gold chain from a bewildered other twin. 

Deanna Supplee & Diana Coates

The town’s unpaid merchant, Balthazar (Diana Coats, of course) and his goldsmith buddy (yep, Deanna Supplee) seek the arrest of the wrong man by the town’s sergeant (Chuckie Benson in a new role) — a cop in a giant cowboy hat and with a drawl who looks and acts like he just walked off the screen of a Mel Brooks’ Wild West farce.

Robert Cornelius

Even a Bible-thumping, revival-preacher named Pinch gets in the act to try and perform an exorcism on the chaos at hand (a hilarious Robert Cornelius).  

In the meantime, unbeknownst to neither Antipholus of S nor of E, his never-seen-since-birth father (Michael J. Asberry) is about to be executed; and his long-lost mother is the town’s head priestess hidden away in the main square’s temple (Robert Cornelius, this time as a sidesplittingly funny, giant nun).

The multiple shifts in roles sometimes occur as the air is split by a sound like a needle scraping across an revolving record (remember that sound when we once all had record players).  All action then stops as those on stage swap outfits, wigs, hats, etc. to take on new roles.  All frantic-paced action is accompanied by a lot of purposeful, over-the-top acting; and there is much back-slapping, high-fiving, and physical teasing and bantering that is an almost constant between the right and the wrong pairs of twins.  

The result is ninety minutes of fun and fury that resembles a mixture of Shakespeare’s original intent, a Vaudeville act, kids’ cartoons, and a TV-sitcom comedy.  Any production of William Shakespeare’s The Comedy of Errors is likely to be filled with exaggerated hilarity.  The Acting Company goes a few steps further in their touring version, turning ACT’s Toni Rembe Theatre into a Pittsburg-turned-Ephesus diner that is full of mad-dash chases and madcap mix-ups.

Rating: 3.5 E

The Comedy of Errors continues through May 3, 2025, in a niney-minute (no intermission) touring production by Acting Company at American Conservatory Theatre, the Toni Rembe Theatre, 415 Geary Street, San Francisco.  Tickets are available online at https://www.act-sf.org, by phone at 415-749-2228, and by email at tickets@act-sf.org.

Photo Credits: Veronica Slavin

Rating: 3.5 E Tags: 3.5 E, American Conservatory Theater, Touring Company, William Shakespeare

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

E-mail Newsletter

Sign up to receive reviews by email

Top 50 Theater Blogs
Eddie is a member of the American Theatre Critics Association and the San Francisco Bay Area Theatre Critics Circle.

Theatre Eddys Ratings Legend

5 E's - Loved It
A classic, would see it a second time.
4 E's - Really Liked It
Excellent, strong production.
3 E's - Liked It
Good production but something is lacking or not clicking.
2 E's - Just OK
Below average but had at least one interesting component.
1 E - Did Not Like It
Waste of time.

Shows By Rating

  • 5 E (414)
  • 4.5 E (83)
  • 4 E (257)
  • 3.5 E (61)
  • 3 E (112)
  • 2.5 E (7)
  • 2 E (20)
  • 1.5 E (1)
  • 1 E (4)
  • Best Bet (160)
  • Not Rated (38)

Shows By Date

Tags

Musical5 Eworld premiereMUST SEE4 ETheatreWorks Silicon ValleySan Francisco PlayhouseNew Conservatory Theatre CenterPear TheatreBerkeley Repertory Company4.5 EMarin Theatre CompanyAmerican Conservatory TheatrePalo Alto PlayersShotgun PlayersAurora Theatre CompanyThe MarshHillbarn TheatreCity Lights Theater CompanyOregon Shakespeare Festival

Footer

About this site

Theatre Eddys reviews performances throughout the greater San Francisco Bay Area.

About Eddie

Theatre Critic for the Greater San Francisco Bay Area, writing 150+ reviews annually for Theatre Eddys and Talkin' Broadway (San Jose/Silicon Valley). Read More

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2014–2025 Theatre Eddys. Website by Refactorr