• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Best Bets
  • Upcoming Shows
  • All Reviews
  • Bay Area Theatres
  • About Eddie
  • Contact
Theatre Eddys

Theatre Eddys

San Francisco Bay Area Theater Reviews

The Producers

April 30, 2023 by Eddie Reynolds

The Producers

Mel Brooks (Book, Music & Lyrics)
Hillbarn Theatre and Conservatory

James M. Jones & Edward Hightower

Perspective #1: Raunchy, crass, insulting, insensitive.  Horrible stereotypes that in 2023 seem particularly out of place in light of Me-Too, Don’t Say Gay, dramatic increase in antisemitism, and attacks in state after state aimed at transgender people.

Perspective #2: Riotous, hilarious, sparkling, toe-tapping.  So over-blown in portraying stereotypes of gays, Jews, Nazis, good-looking blondes, Irish, and old women that the ridicule is actually aimed at all those bigots who still hold such views.

Which is a more accurate overview of the 2001, twelve-Tony-winning The Producers by the grand master of dark comedy in film and on stage, Mel Brooks?  Has enough changed since its Great White Way premiere and huge success that in 2023 the humor of The Producers is just not that funny anymore?  Or is it even more relevant than ever as a way to show vividly how ridiculous those stereotypes are and how stupid and mean-hearted are the people who actually believe and act on them?

Hillbarn Theatre and Conservatory puts the case before its sold-out audience on opening night. Based on the almost constant, universal guffaws; spontaneous rounds of mid-performance applause, and the smiles beaming and approvals buzzing as folks exited, The Producers still is seen for what it is at its heart: an in-your-face, pull-no-punches, laugh-at-loud ridicule of the many stereotypes that unfortunately still haunt our society today.  The case Hillbarn makes for continuing to enjoy Mel Brooks’ always unconventional, sometimes uncomfortable sense of bizarre humor is strengthened by a production that is in every respect big-stage, Broadway quality in an intimate setting where audience and actors are only a few feet apart.

Please continue to Talkin’ Broadway for the rest of my review.

Rating: 4 E

The Producers continues through May 14, 2023, in production by Hillbarn Theatre & Conservatory, 1285 East Hillsdale Blvd., Foster City, CA.  Tickets are available online at http://hillbarntheatre.org , by email at boxoffice@hillbarntheatre.org, or by phone at 650-349-6411.

Please note:  All patrons must wear a well-fitting mask at all times inside the Hillbarn facilities and auditorium.

Photo Credit:  Mark Kitaoka

Rating: 4 E Tags: Musical, Hillbarn Theatre, 4 E

Primary Sidebar

E-mail Newsletter

Sign up to receive reviews by email

Top 50 Theater Blogs
Eddie is a member of the American Theatre Critics Association and the San Francisco Bay Area Theatre Critics Circle.

Theatre Eddys Ratings Legend

5 E's - Loved It
A classic, would see it a second time.
4 E's - Really Liked It
Excellent, strong production.
3 E's - Liked It
Good production but something is lacking or not clicking.
2 E's - Just OK
Below average but had at least one interesting component.
1 E - Did Not Like It
Waste of time.

Shows By Rating

  • 5 E (412)
  • 4.5 E (83)
  • 4 E (255)
  • 3.5 E (61)
  • 3 E (112)
  • 2.5 E (7)
  • 2 E (20)
  • 1.5 E (1)
  • 1 E (4)
  • Best Bet (158)
  • Not Rated (38)

Shows By Date

Tags

Musical5 Eworld premiereMUST SEE4 ETheatreWorks Silicon ValleySan Francisco PlayhouseNew Conservatory Theatre CenterPear TheatreBerkeley Repertory Company4.5 EMarin Theatre CompanyAmerican Conservatory TheatrePalo Alto PlayersShotgun PlayersAurora Theatre CompanyThe MarshHillbarn TheatreCity Lights Theater CompanyOregon Shakespeare Festival

Footer

About this site

Theatre Eddys reviews performances throughout the greater San Francisco Bay Area.

About Eddie

Theatre Critic for the Greater San Francisco Bay Area, writing 150+ reviews annually for Theatre Eddys and Talkin' Broadway (San Jose/Silicon Valley). Read More

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2014–2025 Theatre Eddys. Website by Refactorr